Welcome to our UK site – choose your Jurisdiction

FCA Highlights Good and Poor Practices in Fair Value Assessments Three Years into the Consumer Duty 

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has published new insights into how firms are assessing, evidencing and monitoring fair value under the Consumer Duty, highlighting areas of good practice and opportunities for improvement. 

On 29 October 2026, the FCA published a blog examining how firms are applying the price and value outcome of the Consumer Duty, three years after its introduction. 

The publication draws on the FCA’s recent supervisory work across the consumer finance market, including reviews of firms’ fair value assessments, fees and charges and certain consumer hire arrangements. 

While the FCA acknowledges that many firms have successfully embedded fair value considerations into their product design, pricing and ongoing monitoring, it has also identified weaknesses in how some firms demonstrate that their products and services deliver fair value. 

A central message emerging from the FCA’s findings is that firms must be able to substantiate their fair value conclusions with meaningful evidence rather than relying solely on assumptions or descriptions of product features. 

Key Findings from the FCA’s Review 

  1. Fair Value Assessments Must Be Supported by Meaningful Evidence

The FCA identified clear differences between firms that effectively demonstrated fair value and those whose assessments lacked sufficient supporting evidence. 

Firms demonstrating good practice established a clear relationship between the total price paid by customers and the benefits they could reasonably expect to receive. 

For example, the FCA highlighted a credit card provider that quantified customer benefits, including cashback and foreign exchange savings, and compared these directly against the fees and interest charged. 

In contrast, weaker assessments often relied on assumptions, descriptions of product features or information spread across multiple documents without a clear explanation of how the evidence supported the firm’s conclusions. 

What should firms consider? 

Firms should ensure that their fair value assessments: 

  • Evaluate the relationship between the total price paid and the benefits customers receive; 
  • Use relevant customer data and Management Information (MI) to support conclusions; 
  • Clearly document the rationale behind fair value decisions; 
  • Identify potential areas of customer harm and demonstrate how these are addressed. 

The FCA’s findings reinforce the importance of maintaining a clear and documented assessment process that can withstand regulatory scrutiny. 

  1. Different Customer Groups May Experience Different Outcomes

Another key finding concerns the importance of assessing fair value across different customer groups. 

The FCA observed that firms demonstrating stronger practices segmented their customer bases using factors such as credit risk, product usage, distribution channels and characteristics of vulnerability. 

This enabled firms to identify whether particular groups were paying disproportionately higher prices or receiving fewer benefits compared with other customers. 

Conversely, firms that assessed their entire target market as a single group risked overlooking differences in customer outcomes. 

What should firms consider? 

Firms should consider whether their fair value assessments adequately account for differences between customer groups, including: 

  • Customers with characteristics of vulnerability; 
  • Customers subject to different pricing structures or interest rates; 
  • Customers accessing products through different distribution channels; 
  • Customers with different levels of product usage or engagement. 

By assessing these differences, firms can better identify potential disparities and take appropriate action where fair value concerns arise. 

  1. Customer Understanding Is Essential to Delivering Fair Value

The FCA also emphasised the relationship between fair value and customer understanding. 

Even where a product is appropriately priced, customers may experience poor outcomes if they do not understand the total costs, charges or financial commitments associated with it. 

The FCA identified examples of firms actively testing customer understanding, including contacting customers who incurred particular charges to assess whether they understood how and when those charges applied. 

The publication also highlighted concerns relating to promotional claims for certain long-term consumer hire arrangements involving home energy equipment. In particular, claims suggesting guaranteed savings or affordability could create misleading expectations where actual outcomes depend on uncertain future factors. 

What should firms consider? 

Firms should: 

  • Ensure that pricing information, fees and charges are communicated clearly and transparently; 
  • Assess whether customers understand the total potential cost of products and services; 
  • Review financial promotions and customer communications to identify potentially misleading statements; 
  • Consider testing customer understanding rather than relying exclusively on the provision of disclosures. 

These findings demonstrate the importance of considering the Consumer Duty outcomes collectively rather than treating fair value and customer understanding as separate compliance exercises. 

What Does This Mean for FCA-Regulated Firms? 

The FCA’s latest publication serves as a reminder that compliance with the Consumer Duty is an ongoing responsibility. 

Under PRIN 2A.4, firms are required to assess whether the price consumers pay for a product or service is reasonable compared with the overall benefits they can reasonably expect to receive. 

Firms should also continue monitoring whether their products and services deliver fair value throughout their lifecycle and take appropriate action where concerns are identified. 

Importantly, the FCA recognises that effective assessments do not necessarily require complex modelling or extensive new data collection. Firms, including smaller businesses, may be able to use existing information such as complaints, arrears data, customer feedback and product usage to support their assessments. 

In light of the FCA’s findings, firms should consider reviewing their existing fair value frameworks to establish whether: 

  • Their assessments are supported by sufficient and relevant evidence; 
  • Their analysis appropriately considers different customer groups; 
  • Their pricing structures and associated charges remain justified; 
  • Their customer communications support informed decision-making; 
  • Their governance and monitoring arrangements enable them to identify and address potential poor outcomes. 

Firms should also ensure that their findings, decisions and any resulting actions are appropriately documented and subject to ongoing oversight. 

How Can Complyport Help? 

Complyport supports FCA-regulated firms in implementing, reviewing and enhancing their Consumer Duty frameworks, helping them demonstrate compliance with regulatory expectations and deliver good customer outcomes. 

Our experienced regulatory consultants can assist firms with: 

  • Consumer Duty Gap Assessments: Reviewing existing frameworks, policies and procedures against the FCA’s requirements and identifying areas for improvement. 
  • Fair Value Assessment Reviews: Evaluating the methodology, evidence and conclusions supporting firms’ price and value assessments. 
  • Customer Outcome Monitoring: Supporting the development and enhancement of MI, monitoring arrangements and governance processes to identify potential customer harm. 
  • Customer Communications Reviews: Assessing financial promotions, disclosures and customer journeys against the Consumer Duty’s customer understanding requirements. 
  • Governance and Regulatory Support: Assisting firms with documenting their assessments, strengthening oversight arrangements and addressing regulatory findings. 

Contact Complyport today to discuss how our regulatory specialists can support your firm in reviewing its Consumer Duty arrangements and strengthening its approach to demonstrating fair value. 

Ask ViCA, your Virtual Compliance Assistant. Claim your complimentary 20 queries today! Register here: https://vica.chat 

Why Choose Complyport?

Extensive Regulatory Expertise

With over 25 years of experience in the financial services industry, Complyport offers unparalleled expertise in regulatory compliance, ensuring your firm stays ahead of evolving regulations.

Comprehensive Service Offering

From AML audits to risk management and regulatory reporting, Complyport provides a full spectrum of compliance services, allowing you to streamline your compliance processes and focus on your core business activities.

Tailored Compliance Solutions

We provide bespoke compliance solutions that are specifically designed to meet the unique needs of your business, ensuring that all regulatory requirements are met efficiently and effectively.

Client-Centric Approach

We provide bespoke compliance solutions that are specifically designed to meet the unique needs of your business, ensuring that all regulatory requirements are met efficiently and effectively.

Senior-Level Guidance

Our team of seasoned professionals, including former regulators and industry experts, leads all engagements, offering deep insights and practical advice to help you manage compliance risks effectively.

Innovative Fintech, Regtech and AI Solutions

Leveraging cutting-edge fintech, regtech and AI tools, Complyport enhances your compliance processes with advanced technology, ensuring accuracy, efficiency, and real-time regulatory updates. Our innovative solutions empower your firm to stay compliant while maximising operational efficiency.

Key Figures

Over 25 Years

Providing Compliance Excellence

Over 1,500

Successful FCA, EU and UAE Authorisations

Over 1,000

Active Firms Receiving
Regulatory Support

8 Lots

FCA/PRA Skilled Person
& Consultancy Panel

Get In Touch